Score: 6

"6 out of 10"

submission: Deranged

date: August 2, 2006

Originality: Nothing in this song really stood out as far as originality goes, but it was catchy.

Diversity: Due to the lack of vocals, songs like this tend to get boring as they go along. I suggest to either vary the guitar parts a bit more, or add more instruments (This would include vocals) to make things a bit more interesting.

Clarity: The drums took dominance over the guitar parts in this song, which I'm not really a fan over. The guitar had a GREAT sound to it, but the quality was a bit poor.

Effort: Overall, this was a good song. Nothing outstanding, but it's worth a download.

Score: 8

"Four outta Five"

submission: The Minish Cap; Opening Story

date: April 12, 2006

Nice. Gotta love that lead synth. I've never heard the actual song, so it was pretty original to me. My only advice is to find a better way to end it. It kinda just stopped abruptly. Good job anyways.

Score: 6

"Six outta Ten"

submission: Lufia 2 - Theme of Town

date: March 22, 2006

Haha...everytime I check out the AP one of your songs seems to have just been submitted.

Originality: As I've said before, doing a remake deducts your originality score.

Diversity: You seem to have this bad habit of submitting songs that repeat too much. I think this should have ended about halfway through.

Clarity: It was ok. Nothing special.

Effort: Hard to tell. Once again, you doing a remake marks you down a bit.

Overall: Good song. I've noticed, however, that each of the three songs I've reviewed so far have lacked one thing: RESOLUTION! The song cuts out all of a sudden, and is really annoying. This should definitely be fixed.

Score: 6

"Six outta Ten"

submission: Lufia 2 - The Earth (Sequel)

date: March 21, 2006

I'm not going to write you a full review, seeing as I reviewed the original just moments ago. Everything was nice except for that wind instrument! It was horrible! I heard it and my natural reaction was "EWWWW!!". Fix that up, and you should have yourself a decent song.

Score: 6

"Six outta Ten"

submission: Lufia 2 - The Earth

date: March 21, 2006

Originality: Of course, this IS a remake, so you don't get much for originality.
Diversity: Repeated too much for my taste.
Clarity: Sounded almost MIDI. I'm not saying it is, but it sounded like it...which marks you down for clarity.
Effort: The only reason you didn't recieve a 10 for effort was because you did a remake. If this were an original song, you would've certainly got full points.
Overall: Nice track. Keep 'em coming.

Score: 8

"Eight outta Ten"

submission: The bicycle bell

date: March 21, 2006

Originality: Sounded strange, though in a good way.
Diversity: Repeated a little too much. I got bored with it about halfway through.
Clarity: Not much to be said. Good job.
Effort: Considering it was done in 12 days, I don't think it was that bad at all.
Overall: Good, but there was something missing. I can't quite place my finger on what it was. Perhaps if you fixed up the beat to make it a little more danceable it would be better.

Score: 7

"4 outta 5"

submission: Puritania(cover)

date: March 1, 2006

I love Dimmu Borgir, and this was a great cover of one of my favorite songs. Nice job! Just a suggestion, try a cover of Indoctrination. That would turn out nice. :D

Score: 8

"Pretty Good"

submission: RGH: Castle Guard

date: February 20, 2006

Orig: I was going to give you a 6, cuz I've heard alot of these kind of pieces lately. However, it was slightly different (it had some synth in there) so I eased up a bit.

Div: It repeated a little too much. Nothing to really worry about though. Very nice peace.

Clar: It was a little too quiet. You had some cool stuff going on, but I couldn't hear it that well.

Eff: It sounds like you really tried hard to put these together. Nice job!

Overall: 8/10. You only had a few minor problems. Almost everything was great!

Score: 8

"four outta five"

submission: Blitzkrieg by Flame Mesial

date: February 18, 2006

the quality was horrible, but everything else was fuckn awesome. it was like a trip back into those good old days when pantera ruled the world.

Score: 4

"two outta five"

submission: Tetris Dirty Remix

date: February 13, 2006

no offense, but that song was just annoying. it didnt have any real structure to it...just a whole bunch of random sound effects.